التخطي إلى المحتوى الرئيسي

Why are so many game developers opposed to gamification?

"Gamification" and "bringing game mechanics to serious endeavors" are not necessarily the same thing.
It's hard to talk for all the game developers, but I will give you my take on this issue:
  1. The most basic characteristic about games is they are intrinsically motivated activities which challenge players in a specific skill (I am not talking about other types of play, which are not games by definition). Games are a voluntary activity - because when they are not, they aren't games anymore, they are a chore, a task, a job.
  2. Most of the other extrinsic motivation-creating game mechanics (that include badges, levels, coins, etc.) are not unique to games. Moreover, they are used by organisations for decades (or more?) to generate (extrinsic) motivation (just think about schools and workplaces). I admit that the game industry perfected these extrinsic motivations better than others, as these mechanisms became critical for prolonging user-retention, although its effect on retention is still lower than introducing real challenge (and new content) into the game.
  3. Therefore, Gamification brings nothing new. On the one hand, adding extrinsic motivation to real world activities won't transform them into games (which the word implies, even if it is not the exact defintion). And on the other hand, people have been using these tools to motivate other people for decades without calling them by a cool buzzword.


تعليقات

إرسال تعليق

المشاركات الشائعة من هذه المدونة

What is a KPI - A Key Performance Indicator Meaning

A  Key Performance Indicator  is a measurable value that demonstrates how effectively a company is achieving key business objectives. Organizations use KPIs at multiple levels to evaluate their success at reaching targets. High-level KPIs may focus on the overall performance of the enterprise, while low-level KPIs may focus on processes in departments                           such as sales, marketing or a call center.  lodex solutions 
إرسال تعليق
قراءة المزيد

the best way to learn how to draw

Drawing is a skill which develops as you practice. You're not alone when you say that you're terrible at drawing; all the great artists have started drawing with  stick figures  at some point in their life. Figures like this one - ​The reason why they went ahead from these so called " stick figures"  to something much more, is that they had an insatiable desire within them to draw even better, every time they put their pencil on paper. This shear fact separated them from the rest, and that's the only reason why they were successful in honing their skill to reach where they reached later on in their respective lives. First and foremost, the one great thing that's in your favor is- the fact that you are dedicated to improve your drawing. I say this because it seems that way, as you are asking this question. And this is really important because any art form can not be learned just for the sake of it; there has to be passion, interest, curiosity, and ded...
إرسال تعليق
قراءة المزيد

Become a 3D animation artist

There are really two parts to becoming an animator. For lack of a more elegant way to put it, there's the  computer  part and the  art  part. The computer part is fairly easy to learn: there is a lot of software to get used to, but this mostly requires patience and willingness to experiment.  The usual standard for professional animators is  Autodesk Maya , which you can download for free if you're a student (An on-going professional license is pretty expensive -- most of the times those are sold directly to studios rather than to individuals.).    There several free or low-cost competing products that work on the same basic principles, for example  Source Filmmaker ,  Hash Animation Master,  and  Blender  -- there are of course many differences in detail but all of these work use the same basic concepts.   There are pretty good online resources for all of them, but nothing is as important as time: i...
إرسال تعليق
قراءة المزيد